DIETARY PROTEIN AND LIPID LEVELS ON GROWTH, PHYSIOLOGICAL METABOLISM AND ORGANOLEPTIC QUALITY OF TRIPLOID RAINBOW TROUT
-
摘要:
研究采用3×3双因素实验设计, 配制3个饲料蛋白质水平(35%、40%和45%)和3个饲料脂肪水平(20%、25%和30%)的9种饲料探究饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟(Oncorhynchus mykiss; 初始体重为1.5 kg)生长性能、生理代谢和感官品质的影响。实验结果表明: 在生长性能方面, 蛋白质水平为40%、脂肪水平≥25%的饲料组(P40L25和P40L30组)三倍体虹鳟增重率最高, 且P40L30组饲料系数最低。在生理代谢方面, 高蛋白质饲料(45%)会降低三倍体虹鳟内脏中的脂肪沉积, 并促进肝脏健康; 高脂肪饲料(30%)不会增加肝脏脂肪含量, 同时会提高肝脏抗氧化能力; 然而高蛋白质高脂肪饲料(P45L30)组肠道发生氧化损伤导致消化能力下降进而影响鱼类生长和饲料利用。在感官品质方面, 肌肉红色值在P45L30组最高, 饲料脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肉质和气味无明显影响, 而投喂高蛋白质饲料(45%)会导致肉质下降。综合以上结果, 体重在1.5—2.5 kg生长阶段的三倍体虹鳟饲料中适宜的蛋白质水平为40%, 适宜脂肪水平为≥25%。
Abstract:The study was conducted to estimate the effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on the growth performance, physiological metabolism, and organoleptic quality of triploid rainbow trout weighting 1.5 kg. Nine diets were formulated with three levels of dietary protein (P) (35%, 40%, and 45%) and three levels of lipid (L) (20%, 25%, and 30%) using a 3×3 factorial design. In freshwater cages, 13500 adult female triploid rainbow trout (1.5 kg) were cultured for 8 weeks. Triplicate cages (500 fish per cage) were used as repetitions of each experimental diet. Results showed that the P40L25 and P40L30 groups exhibited the highest weight gain rate, and P40L30 groups showed the lowest feed conversion ratio. High protein diet (45%) reduced lipid deposition in the viscera and promoted liver health, evidenced by lower viscerosomatic and hepatosomatic indices, decreased hepatic lipid content, and favorable plasma lipid profiles, along with higher hepatic lipoprotein lipase and total lipase activities. Additionally, a high lipid diet (30%) could increase fillet lipid content but not hepatic lipid content and enhanced liver antioxidative capacity. However, the group fed a diet with 45% protein and 30% lipid exhibited oxidative damage in the intestine, resulting in reduced digestion efficiency and subsequent decreases in growth and feed utilization. In addition, this group had the highest fillet redness value. Dietary lipid level did not affect fillet texture and odor, while high protein diet (45%) compromised fillet texture, characterized by higher fracturability and lower springiness. In total, for triploid rainbow trout weighting from 1.5—2.5 kg, the recommended P and L level based on growth performance was 40% and ≥25%, P and L based on feed utilization was 40% and ≥30%, P and L based on organoleptic quality was 40% and ≥25%, respectively. These results provide a basis for the establishment of a nutritional database and the development of an efficient and environmentally diet for triploid rainbow trout.
-
Keywords:
- Growth /
- Physiology /
- Quality /
- Nutrition /
- Triploid rainbow trout
-
-
表 1 实验饲料配方及营养成分(%干物质)
Table 1 Formulation and proximate composition of the experimental diets (% dry matter)
原料
Ingredient组别Group P35/L20 P35/L25 P35/L30 P40/L20 P40/L25 P40/L30 P45/L20 P45/L25 P45/L30 红鱼粉
Brown fish meal137 37 37 44 44 44 51 51 51 小麦粉Wheat meal1 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 木薯淀粉
Cassava starch115 15 15 10 10 10 5 5 5 纤维素Cellulose 13.86 8.86 3.86 12.66 7.66 2.66 11.36 6.36 1.36 鱼油Fish oil 13.3 18.3 23.3 12.5 17.5 22.5 11.8 16.8 21.8 豆油Soybean meal 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 多维多矿
Vitamin-mineral premix21 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Ca (H2PO4)2 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 氯化胆碱
Choline chloride0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 丙酸钙
Calcium propionate0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 乙氧基喹啉
Ethoxyquin0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 甜菜碱Betaine 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Y2O3 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 虾青素Astaxanthin3 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 成分分析 Proximate analysis (n=3) 水分Moisture (%) 2.8 3.2 3.7 3.4 2.4 2.4 2.6 2.8 2.7 粗蛋白
Crude protein (% dry matter)36.0 35.8 34.7 40.6 40.4 40.8 45.5 45.5 44.2 粗脂肪
Crude lipid (% dry matter)20.6 25.9 30.4 19.7 24.5 29.3 19.4 25.3 29.4 能量Gross energy (kJ/g) 21.8 23.7 25.2 21.3 23.1 24.9 21.1 23.3 24.6 注: 1红鱼粉, 粗蛋白68.4%, 粗脂肪8.7%; 小麦粉, 粗蛋白17.7%, 粗脂肪1.5%; 木薯淀粉, 粗蛋白0.8%, 粗脂肪 0.1%; 2多维多矿预混料包括0.5%的多维预混料和0.5%的多矿预混料(肉食性鱼类用, 通威农业发展有限公司); 3虾青素: 10% (CAROPHYLL®, 帝斯曼, 荷兰)Note: 1Brown fish meal containing 68.4% crude protein and 8.7% crude lipid. Wheat meal containing 17.7% crude protein and 1.5% crude lipid. Cassava starch containing 0.8% crude protein and 0.1% crude lipid; 2Vitamin-mineral premix included 0.5% vitamin premix and 0.5% mineral premix on the basis of our previous study[2]. 3Astaxanthin: 10% (CAROPHYLL®, DSM, Netherlands) 表 2 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟生长性能的影响
Table 2 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on growth performance of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group初重
Initial
weight
(kg)末重
Final
weight
(kg)成活率
Survival
rate
(%)增重率
Weight gain
rate (%)饲料系数
Feed
conversion
ratio日摄食率
Feeding
rate
(%BW/d)肥满度
Condition
factor脏体比
VSI肝体比
HSI肠长指数
RILP35L20 1.50±
0.192.06±
0.0498.7±
1.031.4±
1.5a1.85±
0.08c0.89±
0.041.89±
0.0210.8±
0.30.77±
0.020.330±
0.005P35L25 1.51±
0.032.12±
0.0597.7±
0.940.1±
1.5bc1.57±
0.07abc0.98±
0.021.92±
0.0311.0±
0.30.79±
0.020.333±
0.009P35L30 1.51±
0.022.11±
0.0496.1±
1.739.6±
1.1ab1.45±
0.08ab0.96±
0.031.99±
0.0411.1±
0.40.82±
0.020.364±
0.006P40L20 1.46±
0.031.98±
0.0596.9±
1.435.1±
1.2ab1.86±
0.11c1.00±
0.051.81±
0.0310.3±
0.30.79±
0.020.344±
0.007P40L25 1.49±
0.042.09±
0.0697.7±
1.041.9±
3.7c1.44±
0.07ab1.00±
0.011.81±
0.0410.6±
0.40.75±
0.020.337±
0.006P40L30 1.45±
0.042.12±
0.0496.0±
0.844.3±
2.2c1.36±
0.11a1.02±
0.011.83±
0.0211.0±
0.40.76±
0.020.338±
0.007P45L20 1.41±
0.021.98±
0.0397.7±
1.141.0±
1.8bc1.48±
0.06ab0.98±
0.031.82±
0.0310.0±
0.30.71±
0.020.319±
0.006P45L25 1.51±
0.032.02±
0.0598.2±
0.334.6±
2.0ab1.59±
0.06abc0.97±
0.041.73±
0.039.7±
0.30.69±
0.010.315±
0.006P45L30 1.46±
0.031.90±
0.0196.4±
0.432.3±
1.0a1.54±
0.09abc0.90±
0.041.76±
0.0210.9±
0.40.68±
0.010.329±
0.006饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 1.51±
0.012.10±
0.02B97.5±
0.737.0±
1.6A1.62±
0.070.94±
0.021.93±
0.02B11.0±
0.2B0.79±
0.01B0.343±
0.004BP40 1.47±
0.022.06±
0.03B96.8±
0.640.5±
1.9B1.56±
0.091.01±
0.021.82±
0.02A10.6±
0.2AB0.76±
0.01B0.339±
0.004BP45 1.46±
0.021.97±
0.02A97.4±
0.436.0±
1.4A1.54±
0.040.95±
0.021.77±
0.02A10.2±
0.2A0.69±
0.01A0.321±
0.004A饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 1.46±
0.022.01±
0.0297.8±
0.635.9±
1.31.73±
0.07Y0.96±
0.031.84±
0.0210.4±
0.20.75±
0.010.332±
0.004XL25 1.50±
0.022.07±
0.0397.8±
0.438.9±
1.51.53±
0.04XY0.98±
0.011.82±
0.0210.5±
0.20.74±
0.010.328±
0.004XL30 1.47±
0.022.04±
0.0496.1±
0.538.8±
1.81.46±
0.05X0.96±
0.021.86±
0.0211.0±
0.20.75±
0.010.343±
0.004Y双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.130 0.004 0.722 0.038 0.429 0.074 0.000 0.049 0.000 0.012 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.237 0.184 0.111 0.149 0.002 0.636 0.083 0.161 0.982 0.014 交互Interaction 0.643 0.158 0.246 0.001 0.018 0.222 0.247 0.771 0.189 0.247 注: 数据表述为平均值±标准误, 同列数据上标不同字母(a, b等, 根据单因素方差分析结果)代表存在饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平显著交互作用(P<0.05), 同列数据上标不同字母(A, B和C, 根据双因素方差分析结果)代表受饲料蛋白质水平的显著影响(P<0.05), 同列数据上标不同字母(X, Y和Z, 根据双因素方差分析结果)代表受饲料脂肪水平的显著影响(P<0.05); 下同Note: Values are presented as mean±S.E.. Data in the same column with different superscripts (a, b,…based on One-way ANOVA) represent that the significant difference is discovered in the interaction (P<0.05), those with different superscripts (A, B, and C based on Two-way ANOVA) represent that the significant difference is discovered in the dietary protein level (P<0.05), and those with different superscripts (X, Y, and Z based on Two-way ANOVA) represent that the significant difference is discovered in the dietary lipid level (P<0.05); The same applies below 表 3 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肝脏和肌肉成分的影响
Table 3 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on liver and fillet tissue compositions of triploid rainbow trout
组别Group 肝脏成分Liver composition 肌肉成分Fillet composition 蛋白质
Crude protein
(mg/g)脂肪
Crude lipid
(mg/g)糖原
Glycogen
(mg/g)蛋白质
Crude protein
(mg/g)脂肪
Crude lipid
(mg/g)糖原
Glycogen
(mg/g)P35L20 61.7±1.2b 96.9±2.5 14.9±1.4a 219±1 81.6±2.0b 0.45±0.02bc P35L25 63.2±1.3bc 99.4±2.5 24.9±0.7d 216±1 91.0±1.2cd 0.41±0.02b P35L30 62.5±1.2bc 91.5±2.5 19.8±0.3bc 213±1 107±2e 0.47±0.02c P40L20 52.5±0.7a 84.4±3.5 18.1±2.9ab 218±0 84.0±2.5bc 0.57±0.02d P40L25 66.8±2.1cd 75.8±1.3 18.2±0.1ab 213±1 98.5±2.0d 0.48±0.03c P40L30 69.6±2.2d 80.7±1.7 21.8±1.0bcd 214±1 95.3±2.6d 0.76±0.02e P45L20 59.0±1.9b 87.9±2.4 23.9±1.4cd 218±2 72.9±2.7a 0.43±0.01bc P45L25 69.2±1.5d 89.7±3.1 22.5±0.2bcd 219±1 84.2±4.7bc 0.26±0.01a P45L30 75.8±0.6e 87.4±2.4 22.7±0.7cd 218±1 81.2±2.9b 0.24±0.01a 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 62.4±0.7A 95.8±1.6C 19.9±1.9A 216±1AB 93.1±2.6B 0.44±0.01B P40 63.3±2.3A 80.1±1.5A 19.4±1.1A 215±1A 92.6±1.9B 0.59±0.03C P45 67.4±2.1B 88.3±1.5B 23.0±0.5B 218±1B 79.4±2.2A 0.31±0.02A 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 58.4±1.3X 90.1±2.0 19.0±1.9X 219±1Y 79.5±1.7X 0.49±0.02Y L25 66.4±1.1Y 87.7±2.6 21.9±1.3Y 216±1X 91.2±2.1Y 0.39±0.02X L30 68.8±1.8Y 86.5±1.6 21.4±0.6Y 215±1X 94.4±2.8Y 0.47±0.05XY 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.000 0.000 0.014 0.003 0.000 0.000 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.000 0.277 0.047 0.001 0.000 0.000 交互Interaction 0.000 0.063 0.008 0.082 0.003 0.000 表 4 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟血浆生化指标的影响
Table 4 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on plasma indexes of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group谷丙转氨酶
ALT (U/L)谷草转氨酶
AST (U/L)总蛋白
TP (g/L)葡萄糖
CLU
(mmol/L)总胆固醇
CHOL
(mmol/L)甘油三酯
TG
(mmol/L)高密度胆固醇
HDL-C
(mmol/L)低密度胆固醇
LDL-C
(mmol/L)P35L20 2.33±0.33 247±10bc 26.1±0.5de 1.10±0.17 8.96±0.72b 1.48±0.04b 2.56±0.20cd 3.82±0.46c P35L25 3.00±0.58 327±7d 23.1±0.5cd 0.70±0.06 7.34±0.81b 1.14±0.05ab 1.98±0.22abc 3.27±0.50abc P35L30 3.00±0.00 311±21d 30.3±2.5e 1.77±0.33 12.4±1.0c 1.47±0.33b 3.00±0.18d 5.86±0.75d P40L20 2.50±0.50 289±14cd 21.5±1.3bcd 1.70±0.10 7.87±0.38b 1.18±0.11ab 2.06±0.11bc 3.17±0.16abc P40L25 2.67±0.33 283±6cd 22.6±1.7cd 1.50±0.30 8.19±0.66b 0.93±0.13a 2.04±0.14bc 3.50±0.32bc P40L30 3.00±0.58 241±11bc 19.5±1.1bc 2.00±0.25 6.89±0.20b 0.76±0.08a 1.72±0.07ab 2.87±0.13abc P45L20 1.50±0.50 182±31a 16.4±2.9b 0.80±0.10 4.35±0.58a 0.70±0.20a 1.41±0.37ab 2.35±0.50ab P45L25 2.00±0.00 321±14d 23.6±1.6cd 1.25±0.15 8.35±0.38b 0.93±0.10a 1.88±0.21abc 3.24±0.39abc P45L30 1.00±0.00 214±15ab 11.2±0.4a 1.13±0.17 3.77±0.01a 0.63±0.13a 1.29±0.29a 2.05±0.43a 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 2.78±0.22B 288±16B 26.5±1.5B 1.19±0.19A 9.20±0.84B 1.39±0.12B 2.45±0.18B 4.13±0.47B P40 2.75±0.25B 271±11B 21.2±0.8A 1.73±0.14B 7.65±0.30B 0.95±0.08A 1.94±0.08A 3.18±0.14A P45 1.50±0.22A 239±28A 17.0±2.4A 1.07±0.10A 5.49±0.93A 0.75±0.09A 1.53±0.17A 2.55±0.28A 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 2.14±0.26 240±19X 21.3±1.7 1.25±0.15 7.40±0.75X 1.12±0.13 2.01±0.21 3.12±0.29 L25 2.63±0.26 310±10Y 23.0±0.8 1.14±0.17 7.91±0.39Y 0.98±0.06 1.97±0.10 3.34±0.21 L30 2.50±0.38 255±20X 20.2±3.0 1.63±0.18 7.56±1.36XY 0.95±0.17 1.88±0.27 3.31±0.61 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.002 0.005 0.000 0.023 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.002 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.128 0.001 0.056 0.108 0.014 0.783 0.377 0.108 交互Interaction 0.085 0.008 0.002 0.131 0.000 0.023 0.045 0.027 表 5 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟消化酶活性的影响
Table 5 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on digestive enzymes activities of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group淀粉酶Amylase (U/mg prot) 脂肪酶Lipase (U/g prot) 蛋白酶Protease (U/mg prot) 胃
Stomach幽门垂
Pyloric caeca肠
Intestine胃
Stomach幽门垂
Pyloric caeca肠
Intestine胃
Stomach幽门垂
Pyloric caeca肠
IntestineP35L20 0.18±0.01a 0.23±0.01ab 0.14±0.01a 1.09±0.03a 1.38±0.20bc 0.62±0.09a 3.45±0.12bc 4.45±0.54 0.32±0.01a P35L25 0.18±0.01a 0.26±0.01b 0.16±0.01ab 0.83±0.07a 0.81±0.06ab 0.76±0.04a 3.22±0.10b 4.84±0.17 1.55±0.10b P35L30 0.19±0.02a 0.21±0.01ab 0.20±0.02ab 1.19±0.09ab 0.81±0.07ab 1.11±0.10a 3.98±0.11d 4.02±0.07 1.56±0.45b P40L20 0.18±0.00a 0.17±0.00a 0.17±0.01ab 1.04±0.09a 0.72±0.07a 0.68±0.07a 2.64±0.00a 2.71±0.12 2.17±0.11b P40L25 0.16±0.01a 0.17±0.01a 0.15±0.00ab 1.15±0.04ab 0.77±0.03ab 0.73±0.09a 3.77±0.08cd 2.66±0.17 0.27±0.01a P40L30 0.36±0.02bc 0.45±0.02e 0.44±0.03d 2.66±0.22d 3.36±0.17e 2.69±0.14b 10.8±0.2g 1.31±0.34 2.13±0.32b P45L20 0.31±0.01b 0.38±0.02cd 0.31±0.05c 1.79±0.03c 2.93±0.32de 2.43±0.40b 8.25±0.06f 13.8±3.8 0.11±0.01a P45L25 0.37±0.04c 0.40±0.02de 0.20±0.02b 1.53±0.15bc 2.73±0.21d 2.50±0.30b 8.74±0.19f 18.8±3.2 0.38±0.12a P45L30 0.31±0.03b 0.33±0.04c 0.20±0.01ab 1.85±0.17c 1.95±0.34c 2.45±0.31b 5.95±0.33e 13.3±3.3 0.32±0.01a 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 0.19±0.01A 0.23±0.01A 0.16±0.01A 1.03±0.06A 0.97±0.10A 0.85±0.08A 3.55±0.15A 4.44±0.21A 1.14±0.29B P40 0.22±0.03A 0.25±0.04A 0.24±0.04B 1.66±0.25B 1.69±0.40A 1.43±0.31A 5.72±1.61AB 2.22±0.31A 1.52±0.40B P45 0.33±0.02B 0.37±0.02B 0.23±0.02B 1.72±0.08B 2.54±0.20B 2.46±0.17B 7.65±0.55B 15.3±1.9B 0.27±0.06A 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 0.22±0.02X 0.25±0.03X 0.20±0.03XY 1.33±0.12X 1.70±0.33X 1.19±0.29X 4.78±1.11X 6.98±2.39 0.86±0.41X L25 0.23±0.03X 0.28±0.03X 0.17±0.01X 1.17±0.11X 1.50±0.30X 1.27±0.28X 5.24±1.11Y 8.78±3.31 0.73±0.26X L30 0.28±0.03Y 0.32±0.03Y 0.27±0.04Y 1.90±0.20Y 2.04±0.33Y 2.08±0.24Y 6.89±1.28Z 6.21±2.45 1.34±0.37Y 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.002 0.001 0.000 0.000 0.002 0.000 0.000 0.319 0.010 交互Interaction 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.659 0.000 表 6 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肝脏代谢酶活性的影响
Table 6 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on hepatic metabolism enzymes of triploid rainbow trout
组别Group 氨基酸代谢酶Amino acid metabolism enzyme 脂肪代谢酶Lipid metabolism enzyme 谷氨酸脱氢酶
GDH (U/mg prot)谷丙转氨酶
ALT (U/g prot)谷草转氨酶
AST (U/g prot)肝酯酶
HL (U/mg prot)脂蛋白酯酶
LPL (U/mg prot)总酯酶
TL (U/mg prot)P35L20 36.5±0.6g 8.13±0.75ab 16.1±0.4abc 0.69±0.04b 0.66±0.02cd 1.34±0.05cd P35L25 23.1±0.3e 8.86±1.21ab 19.4±1.7c 0.63±0.02b 0.56±0.01bc 1.18±0.03bc P35L30 26.3±0.4f 7.63±0.05ab 18.9±0.6bc 0.61±0.03b 0.48±0.03ab 1.09±0.03b P40L20 16.3±0.2c 9.69±0.42b 23.6±1.2d 0.81±0.05c 0.83±0.06ef 1.64±0.09ef P40L25 13.1±0.3b 8.62±0.76ab 18.0±0.6bc 0.58±0.02ab 0.72±0.04de 1.30±0.05cd P40L30 18.4±0.2d 6.62±0.43a 14.5±1.6ab 0.61±0.04b 0.87±0.06f 1.47±0.09de P45L20 11.1±0.4a 8.84±0.39ab 15.6±2.7abc 0.90±0.04c 0.87±0.06f 1.78±0.10f P45L25 18.9±0.1d 6.76±0.25a 16.5±1.4abc 0.66±0.05b 0.59±0.03bcd 1.25±0.03bc P45L30 22.7±0.3e 7.99±1.03ab 12.7±1.3a 0.48±0.03a 0.42±0.05a 0.90±0.05a 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 28.6±2.0B 8.21±0.46 18.1±0.7B 0.64±0.02 0.56±0.03A 1.20±0.04A P40 15.9±0.8A 8.31±0.48 18.7±1.3B 0.67±0.04 0.81±0.03B 1.47±0.06B P45 17.6±1.7A 7.86±0.43 14.9±1.1A 0.68±0.06 0.63±0.06A 1.31±0.11AB 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 21.3±3.9Y 8.88±0.34Y 18.4±1.4 0.80±0.04Y 0.79±0.04Y 1.59±0.07Y L25 18.4±1.5X 8.08±0.52XY 18.0±0.8 0.62±0.02X 0.62±0.03X 1.25±0.02X L30 22.5±1.2Z 7.41±0.38X 15.4±1.0 0.57±0.03X 0.59±0.07X 1.15±0.08X 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.000 0.563 0.027 0.585 0.000 0.001 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.000 0.045 0.055 0.000 0.000 0.000 交互Interaction 0.000 0.040 0.011 0.008 0.002 0.000 表 7 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟抗氧化能力的影响
Table 7 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on antioxidative capacity of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group总抗氧化力T-AOC 丙二醛MDA 蛋白质羰基PC 血浆
Plasma
(mmol/L)肠道
Intestine
(mmol/g prot)肝脏
Liver
(mmol/g prot)血浆
Plasma
(nmol/L)肠道
Intestine
(nmol/g prot)肝脏Liver
(nmol/g
prot)血浆
Plasma
(nmol/L)肠道
Intestine
(nmol/g prot)肝脏Liver
(nmol/g
prot)P35L20 1.71±0.03f 0.32±0.04bcd 0.33±0.03ab 7.48±0.12bcd 9.93±0.61abc 1.19±0.07c 2.70±0.15d 33.9±0.3e 15.3±0.5bc P35L25 2.05±0.10g 0.43±0.05d 0.49±0.03c 7.18±0.28abc 13.6±1.2abc 0.94±0.09bc 2.15±0.01c 26.3±0.8c 13.8±1.3abc P35L30 1.30±0.11de 0.30±0.03bc 0.63±0.04d 9.75±0.26e 7.56±0.62a 0.59±0.02a 1.46±0.02a 31.0±0.7d 11.2±0.4a P40L20 1.51±0.12ef 0.26±0.05ab 0.23±0.02a 8.99±1.09de 8.98±0.90ab 0.76±0.05ab 2.18±0.02c 17.8±0.2b 13.5±2.0abc P40L25 1.26±0.15de 0.39±0.05cd 0.38±0.04b 8.07±0.65cd 9.23±1.07abc 0.89±0.13b 2.04±0.29bc 23.8±0.6c 12.8±0.3ab P40L30 1.05±0.03cd 0.28±0.03bc 0.38±0.06b 6.41±0.26ab 13.0±3.0abc 0.85±0.14ab 1.74±0.01abc 17.0±1.5b 14.4±0.2bc P45L20 0.76±0.03b 0.15±0.02a 0.32±0.03ab 5.72±0.26a 14.5±2.6bc 0.97±0.06bc 1.94±0.19bc 15.6±0.5ab 13.5±0.1abc P45L25 0.46±0.02a 0.16±0.01a 0.30±0.03ab 6.42±0.39ab 15.5±2.5c 1.02±0.11bc 1.87±0.09abc 13.9±0.8a 16.4±0.4c P45L30 0.94±0.09bc 0.34±0.02bcd 0.34±0.05ab 7.04±0.20abc 35.2±3.4d 0.95±0.09bc 1.64±0.04ab 15.9±0.9ab 15.7±0.0bc 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 1.69±0.10C 0.35±0.03B 0.49±0.04B 8.14±0.37B 10.4±0.9A 0.91±0.08AB 2.10±0.23B 30.4±1.4 C 13.4±0.8 P40 1.28±0.08B 0.31±0.03AB 0.33±0.03A 7.83±0.51B 10.2±1.0A 0.83±0.06A 1.99±0.11AB 19.5±1.4 B 13.6±0.6 P45 0.72±0.07A 0.23±0.03A 0.32±0.02A 6.45±0.23A 22.4±3.4B 0.98±0.05B 1.82±0.08A 15.1±0.5A 15.2±0.6 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 1.33±0.13Y 0.25±0.03X 0.29±0.02X 7.55±0.55 10.8±1.0X 0.97±0.06Y 2.27±0.15Y 22.5±3.7 14.1±0.7 L25 1.25±0.20Y 0.34±0.04Y 0.40±0.03Y 7.22±0.32 12.8±1.2XY 0.95±0.06Y 2.02±0.09Y 21.3±2.4 14.4±0.8 L30 1.10±0.06X 0.31±0.02XY 0.45±0.05Y 7.73±0.45 19.1±4.1Y 0.80±0.07X 1.61±0.05X 21.3±3.1 13.8±0.9 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.000 0.002 0.000 0.001 0.000 0.039 0.070 0.000 0.054 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.025 0.038 0.000 0.398 0.000 0.004 0.001 0.170 0.710 交互Interaction 0.000 0.006 0.017 0.001 0.000 0.005 0.045 0.000 0.023 表 8 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肌肉常规指标和肌肉颜色的影响
Table 8 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on fillet biometrical parameters and color of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group肌肉常规指标Fillet biometrical parameter 肌肉肉色Fillet color 出肉率FY (%) 鱼片长指数RFL 肌肉厚度FT (mm) 亮度值L* 红色值a* 黄色值b* 色度值Cab* 色调角Hab° P35L20 62.4±0.8 0.765±0.004 25.7±0.8 46.3±1.0e 16.3±0.3c 22.9±0.3e 28.2±0.4d 54.6±0.6c P35L25 65.2±0.3 0.759±0.004 26.8±0.8 46.0±0.9de 14.3±0.4b 21.0±0.2d 25.4±0.4c 55.2±0.7c P35L30 65.2±0.5 0.749±0.004 25.6±0.9 44.2±1.1cde 14.0±0.3b 18.0±0.4b 22.7±0.5ab 52.7±0.5b P40L20 63.4±2.5 0.748±0.004 26.7±0.9 41.6±1.0abc 13.1±0.2a 16.9±0.3a 21.5±0.3a 51.6±0.6b P40L25 64.9±0.6 0.757±0.004 25.7±0.9 46.2±1.1e 12.8±0.2a 19.3±0.4c 23.2±0.4b 56.1±0.6c P40L30 64.2±0.4 0.752±0.006 25.6±1.0 43.2±1.1bcd 14.2±0.2b 18.4±0.4bc 23.1±0.5b 52.2±0.5b P45L20 62.9±0.8 0.747±0.004 23.8±1.0 42.4±0.8abc 17.0±0.3cd 21.4±0.3d 27.4±0.4d 51.3±0.5b P45L25 62.4±0.4 0.736±0.005 24.9±1.0 40.5±0.9ab 17.0±0.3cd 19.5±0.5c 25.8±0.7c 48.2±0.7a P45L30 62.9±0.4 0.732±0.004 25.0±1.0 40.2±0.7a 17.3±0.2d 19.4±0.4c 25.9±0.5c 48.4±0.5a 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 64.3±0.4 0.757±0.002B 26.0±0.5B 45.5±0.6C 14.9±0.2B 20.6±0.3B 25.4±0.3B 54.2±0.4B P40 64.2±0.8 0.752±0.003B 26.0±0.5B 43.7±0.6B 13.4±0.1A 18.2±0.2A 22.6±0.3A 53.3±0.4B P45 62.7±0.3 0.738±0.002A 24.6±0.6A 41.1±0.5A 17.1±0.2C 20.1±0.3B 26.4±0.3C 49.3±0.4A 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 62.9±0.9 0.753±0.002 25.4±0.6 43.5±0.6 15.5±0.2Y 20.3±0.3Y 25.6±0.4Y 52.5±0.4Y L25 64.2±0.3 0.750±0.003 25.8±0.5 44.2±0.6 14.7±0.3X 19.9±0.2Y 24.8±0.3XY 53.3±0.5Y L30 64.1±0.3 0.745±0.003 25.4±0.6 42.5±0.6 15.1±0.2XY 18.6±0.2X 24.0±0.3X 51.1±0.4X 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.325 0.000 0.035 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.188 0.079 0.715 0.194 0.001 0.000 0.000 0.000 交互Interaction 0.906 0.571 0.353 0.006 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 表 9 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肌肉肉质的影响
Table 9 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on fillet texture of triploid rainbow trout
组别
Group脆性
Fracturability (N)硬度
Hardness (N)黏附性
Adhesiveness (mJ)弹性
Springiness (mm)咀嚼性
Chewiness (mJ)内聚性
CohesivenessP35L20 6.26±0.18 7.65±0.11b 2.29±0.19a 12.6±0.4 23.8±0.7e 0.255±0.005e P35L25 6.27±0.13 7.35±0.15b 2.69±0.18ab 13.3±0.4 24.3±0.6e 0.250±0.003de P35L30 5.66±0.17 7.58±0.18b 2.61±0.18ab 12.4±0.5 21.7±0.7d 0.238±0.005cd P40L20 6.08±0.14 7.35±0.14b 3.04±0.18bc 13.6±0.5 23.3±0.8de 0.246±0.004de P40L25 5.63±0.12 6.68±0.09a 2.22±0.14a 12.2±0.5 18.5±0.6c 0.229±0.003c P40L30 5.73±0.14 7.19±0.14b 3.51±0.14c 11.6±0.6 17.3±0.8bc 0.215±0.004b P45L20 6.22±0.25 7.43±0.12b 5.25±0.19d 8.18±0.57 12.2±0.6a 0.200±0.003a P45L25 6.06±0.20 8.23±0.23c 6.17±0.19e 9.11±0.58 13.6±0.5a 0.199±0.003a P45L30 6.38±0.26 8.25±0.19c 6.91±0.22f 8.99±0.52 15.6±0.6b 0.209±0.004ab 饲料蛋白质水平Dietary protein level (%) P35 6.06±0.10AB 7.52±0.09B 2.53±0.11A 12.8±0.3B 23.3±0.4C 0.248±0.003C P40 5.81±0.08A 7.07±0.08A 2.94±0.11B 12.4±0.3B 19.3±0.5B 0.230±0.003B P45 6.20±0.13B 7.97±0.11C 6.11±0.14C 8.77±0.32A 13.8±0.4A 0.203±0.002A 饲料脂肪水平Dietary lipid level (%) L20 6.18±0.11 7.47±0.07 3.50±0.18X 11.5±0.4 19.4±0.8 0.234±0.004Y L25 5.98±0.10 7.42±0.12 3.69±0.22XY 11.5±0.4 18.3±0.6 0.226±0.003XY L30 5.87±0.11 7.66±0.11 4.28±0.23Y 11.0±0.4 18.1±0.5 0.221±0.003X 双因素方差分析Two-way ANOVA 饲料蛋白质水平
Dietary protein level0.021 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 饲料脂肪水平
Dietary lipid level0.174 0.118 0.000 0.694 0.130 0.001 交互Interaction 0.080 0.000 0.000 0.538 0.000 0.000 表 10 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对三倍体虹鳟肌肉气味活性物质的影响
Table 10 Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on fillet odor active compounds of triploid rainbow trout
气味物质
odor Compounds组别Group 双因素方差分析
Two-way assayP35L20 P35L25 P35L30 P40L20 P40L25 P40L30 P45L20 P45L25 P45L30 P L P×L 1-庚醇
1-Heptanol31.9±6.4 26.7±2.7 34.1±3.9 45.8±5.2 52.6±7.4 46.4±5.4 42.5±3.4 36.0±5.3 46.8±2.7 0.000 0.690 0.545 1-辛烯-3-醇
1-Octen-3-ol122±20 116±11 114±14 149±20 171±36 178±24 175±16 146±24 176±12 0.006 0.837 0.819 2, 3-戊二酮
2, 3-Pentanedione80.3±18.5 109±12 85.9±11.7 54.6±8.6 93.2±12.8 80.2±11.0 49.0±5.1 72.7±8.3 66.7±4.3 0.034 0.005 0.858 2, 3-辛二酮
2, 3-Octanedione84.9±17.5 100±13 74.8±8.7 55.1±4.9 110±18 70.9±6.4 51.1±4.1 100±11 79.3±6.4 0.665 0.000 0.274 3, 5-辛二烯-2-酮
3, 5-Octadien-2-one116±25a 227±42b 188±40ab 114±19a 108±19a 137±14a 159±13ab 148±21a 128±9a 0.014 0.303 0.042 己醛Hexanal 539±94 504±51 433±49 506±66 612±110 550±72 536±53 423±57 449±27 0.282 0.667 0.596 (E)-2-己烯醛
(E)-2-Hexenal16.3±3.4 20.0±2.4 19.3±2.2 18.7±1.8 21.5±2.0 25.8±3.7 21.2±1.3 14.1±1.8 19.2±1.4 0.087 0.254 0.115 庚醛Heptanal 75.4±13.2 88.0±10.1 70.7±8.6 81.8±8.2 100±15 86.9±9.0 72.4±6.5 68.9±6.9 75.1±2.9 0.218 0.663 0.952 (Z)-2-庚烯醛
(Z)-2-Heptadienal54.6±12.3 51.0±4.8 81.6±16.6 65.9±5.7 55.9±7.5 64.7±8.1 59.5±4.5 50.3±7.2 64.8±4.1 0.926 0.095 0.556 辛醛Octanal 81.7±15.3 112±12 111±13 111±9 118±14 113±11 101±9 101±11 109±4 0.347 0.194 0.792 (E,E)-2,4-庚二烯醛
(E,E)-2,4-Heptadienal15.8±4.4 25.4±4.8 19.3±2.2 14.7±1.7 24.0±2.9 24.0±3.4 18.0±1.0 15.5±2.3 16.9±1.7 0.218 0.041 0.136 (E)-2-辛烯醛
(E)-2-Octenal18.3±4.5 23.6±3.1 20.1±2.7 17.2±1.7 20.6±2.3 21.6±2.5 19.3±1.8 15.8±2.1 18.7±1.5 0.689 0.721 0.756 壬醛Nonanal 115±23 180±21 138±26 131±16 151±21 126±19 132±21 143±14 162±10 0.665 0.209 0.617 (E,Z)-2,6-壬二醛
(E,Z)-2,6-Nonadienal16.4±4.1 24.3±3.8 19.9±2.6 15.2±1.3 15.5±1.9 18.3±2.5 18.0±2.1 14.7±2.1 19.9±2.0 0.282 0.460 0.252 (E)-2-壬烯醛
(E)-2-Nonenal11.3±2.7 15.9±2.1 8.60±1.07 7.55±0.71 9.72±1.39 9.51±1.11 9.62±1.77 9.02±0.95 11.5±1.2 0.120 0.235 0.072 癸醛Decanal 13.8±3.2 23.3±2.4 21.0±4.7 17.0±1.8 16.7±1.8 13.6±1.6 14.3±1.9 15.0±1.5 19.4±1.1 0.277 0.241 0.144 十一醛
Undecanal8.43±1.49a 23.8±2.9cd 20.4±4.1bcd 19.0±2.1bcd 17.5±1.9bc 15.4±2.2b 16.3±2.3bc 19.0±1.1bcd 26.2±2.0d 0.097 0.014 0.001 2-乙基-呋喃
2-Ethy-furan13.2±2.4 17.3±2.5 18.3±3.4 12.7±1.3 15.1±1.9 15.8±2.0 12.8±1.0 13.1±1.4 13.0±0.8 0.129 0.093 0.772 2-戊基-呋喃
2-Pentyl-furan6.65±1.36 10.1±1.4 7.69±1.06 7.45±0.77 7.09±1.07 7.24±0.65 7.19±0.88 6.35±1.00 6.85±0.48 0.362 0.511 0.331 总计Total 1420±256 1694±173 1467±182 1443±146 1720±288 1624±193 1514±123 1395±176 1508±74 0.837 0.484 0.918 ∑n-3降解产物
∑n-3 derived232±50 375±65 344±55 241±26 235±31 286±32 288±20 265±32 261±12 0.127 0.321 0.156 ∑n-6降解产物
∑n-6 derived772±132 752±79 648±81 768±95 929±183 854±105 820±75 669±91 737±43 0.281 0.848 0.696 ∑n-9降解产物
∑n-9 derived318±59 430±41 373±51 387±37 438±55 386±41 362±40 364±38 413±18 0.715 0.320 0.833 -
[1] 农业农村部渔业渔政管理局, 全国水产技术推广总站, 中国水产学会. 2023中国渔业统计年鉴 [M]. 北京: 中国农业出版社, 2023: 25. Bureau of Fisheries, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, National Fisheries Technology Extension Center, China Society of Fisheries. 2023 China Fishery Statistical Year Book [M]. Beijing: China Agriculture Press, 2023: 25.
[2] Ma R, Liu X, Meng Y, et al. Protein nutrition on sub-adult triploid rainbow trout (1): Dietary requirement and effect on anti-oxidative capacity, protein digestion and absorption [J]. Aquaculture, 2019(507): 428-434. doi: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2019.03.069
[3] 韩步鹰, 孟玉琼, 刘小红, 等. 饲料蛋白质水平对三倍体虹鳟生长和肠道组织形态的影响 [J]. 水产学杂志, 2020, 33(1): 1-7. Han B Y, Meng Y Q, Liu X H, et al. Effect of dietary protein levels on growth and intestinal histological morphology of triploid rainbow trout [J]. Chinese Journal of Fisheries, 2020, 33(1): 1-7.
[4] Cao S, Guan L, Li C, et al. Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on growth, metabolism, antioxidative capacity, and fillet quality of adult triploid rainbow trout farmed in net cage [J]. Aquaculture Nutrition, 2023(2023): 4733343.
[5] Gao W, Liu Y, Tian L, et al. Protein-sparing capability of dietary lipid in herbivorous and omnivorous freshwater finfish: a comparative case study on grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) and tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus × O. aureus) [J]. Aquaculture Nutrition, 2011, 17(1): 2-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2095.2009.00698.x
[6] Meng Y, Qian K, Ma R, et al. Effects of dietary lipid levels on sub-adult triploid rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss): 1. Growth performance, digestive ability, health status and expression of growth-related genes [J]. Aquaculture, 2019(513): 734394. doi: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2019.734394
[7] Meng Y, Tian H, Hu X, et al. Effects of dietary lipid levels on the lipid deposition and metabolism of subadult triploid rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) [J]. Aquaculture Nutrition, 2022(2022): 6924835.
[8] Liu G, Chen L, Tian H, et al. Adult triploid rainbow trout can adapt to various dietary lipid levels by coordinating metabolism in different tissues [J]. Metabolites, 2023, 13(3): 396. doi: 10.3390/metabo13030396
[9] Meng Y, Liu X, Guan L, et al. Does dietary lipid level affect the quality of triploid rainbow trout and how should it be assessed [J]? Foods, 2022, 12(1): 15. doi: 10.3390/foods12010015
[10] Horwitz W. Official Methods of Analysis of AOAC International [M]. 17th edition, Gaithersburg (Maryland). Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC) International, 2005: 1-44.
[11] Folch J, Lees M, Sloane-Stanley G H. A simple method for the isolation and purification of total lipides from animal tissues [J]. The Journal of Biological Chemistry, 1957, 226(1): 497-509. doi: 10.1016/S0021-9258(18)64849-5
[12] Xu H, Bi Q, Meng X, et al. Response of lipid and fatty acid composition of turbot to starvation under different dietary lipid levels in the previous feeding period [J]. Food Research International, 2022(151): 110905. doi: 10.1016/j.foodres.2021.110905
[13] 张姚铮泰, 谢凯, 石勇, 等. 饲料蛋白质和脂肪水平对丝尾鳠幼鱼生长、血清生化指标及肝脏抗氧化能力的影响 [J]. 水生生物学报, 2024, 48(6): 968-978. Zhangyao Z T, Xie K, Shi Y, et al. Dietary protein and lipid level on growth, serum biochemical index and liver antioxidant capacity of juvenile Asian red-tailed catfish (Hemibagrus wyckioides) [J]. Acta Hydrobiologica Sinica, 2024, 48(6): 968-978.
[14] 美国科学院国家研究委员会. 鱼类与甲壳类营养需要 [M]. 北京: 科学出版社. 2015: 75-77. National Research Council of the American Academy of Sciences. Nutrient Requirement of Fish and Shrimp [M]. Beijing: Science Press. 2015: 75-77.
[15] Meng Y, Han B, Li C, et al. Digestive characteristics and blood chemistry profile of triploid rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss: influence of body size and seasonal variation [J]. Fisheries Science, 2019, 85(6): 1001-1010. doi: 10.1007/s12562-019-01348-6
[16] García-Meilán I, Ordóñez-Grande B, Machahua C, et al. Effects of dietary protein-to-lipid ratio on digestive and absorptive processes in sea bass fingerlings [J]. Aquaculture, 2016(463): 163-173. doi: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2016.05.039
[17] Meng Y, Li C, Qin Q, et al. Dietary lipid levels affect the growth performance, lipid deposition, and antioxidative capacity of juvenile scaleless carp, Gymnocypris przewalskii, on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau [J]. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society, 2018, 49(4): 788-797. doi: 10.1111/jwas.12474
[18] Xu Z, Zhang P, Chang Q, et al. Effects of dietary protein and lipid levels on growth performance, muscle composition, immunity index and biochemical index of the greenfin horse-faced filefish (Thamnaconus septentrionalis) juvenile [J]. Journal of Ocean University of China, 2021, 20(5): 1245-1252. doi: 10.1007/s11802-021-4885-y
[19] Chen Y, Yang H, Guo B, et al. Dietary effects of protein and lipid levels on growth performance and flesh quality of large-size largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) [J]. Aquaculture Reports, 2023(33): 101852. doi: 10.1016/j.aqrep.2023.101852
[20] 陈拥军, 林仕梅, 罗莉, 等. 饲料油脂氧化对养殖鱼类生长及健康的危害 [J]. 水生生物学报, 2016, 40(3): 624-633. Chen Y J, Lin S M, Luo L, et al. Detrimental effects of dietary oil oxidation on growth and health status of fish [J]. Acta Hydrobiologica Sinica, 2016, 40(3): 624-633.
[21] Periago M J, Ayala M D, López-Albors O, et al. Muscle cellularity and flesh quality of wild and farmed sea bass, Dicentrarchus labrax L [J]. Aquaculture, 2005(249): 175-188. doi: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2005.02.047
[22] 卓琳莹, 管玲玲, 鲍守民, 等. 二、三倍体虹鳟肌肉感官品质差异的对比分析 [J]. 食品科学, 2022, 43(18): 209-215. Zhuo L Y, Guan L L, Bao S M, et al. Comparison of sensory quality between diploid and triploid rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) muscles [J]. Food Science, 2022, 43(18): 209-215.
[23] 管玲玲, 刘小红, 田海宁等. 不同养殖模式下三倍体虹鳟鱼肉品质差异的研究 [J]. 水生生物学报, 2022, 46(7): 1016-1028. Guan L L, Liu X H, Tian H N, et al. Fillet quality difference of triploid rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) cultured under different modes [J]. Acta Hydrobiologica Sinica, 2022, 46(7): 1016-1028.
[24] Guan L, Zhuo L, Tian H, et al. Canola oil substitution doesn’t affect growth but alters fillet quality of triploid rainbow trout [J]. Aquaculture, 2023(569): 739385. doi: 10.1016/j.aquaculture.2023.739385
[25] Ma R, Liu X, Tian H, et al. Odor-active volatile compounds profile of triploid rainbow trout with different marketable sizes [J]. Aquaculture Reports, 2020(17): 100312. doi: 10.1016/j.aqrep.2020.100312
计量
- 文章访问数: 298
- HTML全文浏览量: 68
- PDF下载量: 44